On Santa and parenting.
Hm. I'm sort of thinking my post yesterday didn't come across as light-hearted as I meant it. I particularly thought you were being a little harsh, Brandon, but maybe I also did not read your comment as light-hearted as YOU meant it. Look, I was kind of poking fun at me & Davey, saying LOOK HOW WE THINK WE'RE GOING TO BE SO AWESOME but I certainly know by watching other friends and reading plenty of mommy blogs that priorities shift and change, and we will do things we never thought we would do before we actually have a kid. I mean, IF we can have a kid. Serious parenting philosophy discussions are sort of jumping the gun at this stage, which is why I didn't really mean that post too seriously.
When I was growing up, Santa visited and I went to McDonald's once in a blue moon for other kids' birthday parties, and we went to church. I don't think any of that scarred me for life, and I don't think my mom (or any parent who does the same) was a bad person for it. I don't consider her a liar because she told me about Santa and god. I just personally don't think I can do it. Let them believe in dragons and unicorns and even Santa if they want to - and frankly, they probably will, because just as you say, we won't be the only influence on them - but I don't really feel comfortable perpetuating the Santa thing (I can live with dragons and unicorns, because that's a different kind of myth). And that has a lot to do with the crazy consumerism of Christmas now - one reason I don't think my mom was bad for doing the Santa thing is that it wasn't out of control back then. But marketing & media has changed the magic of that forever, to me, so I don't really want to be a part of it. I also can't really reconcile how I can tell someone that god is not real but Santa is. And I DO remember feeling really disappointed when I finally learned Santa wasn't real.
Why would I even celebrate Christmas at all? I've never made a secret of the fact it is not my favorite holiday, so maybe if I lived in a vacuum I wouldn't. But my family loves it, and Davey's huge family loves it, and there are a lot of them that come in from out of town, so to reject Christmas at this stage is more about rejecting family than god. And I'm not going to do that, as tiresome as I do find it quite a lot of the time. It's also really nice a lot of the time. Our families aren't religious, so it is pretty easy to frame something like that in terms of "This is a time of year when everyone is able to get together at the same time" so it is a Family Holiday as opposed to a Religious Holiday.
I guess I particularly felt this was a little harsh: "i don't consider myself a liar for not telling them when they were born that santa isn't real any more than i don't consider myself a liar for not telling them that while they are opening $400 worth of presents that 20% of African children will die before the age of 5". I don't even really know how to respond to that. Not that I have to, but it hurt my feelings a little, because it makes me feel that you feel I'm being self-righteous about this stuff. I guess first of all, by saying I don't want to perpetuate any myths of imaginary bearded dudes (whether in clouds or red suits) doesn't mean I want any child I may have to have a miserable childhood only confronted with what can be confirmed by facts and statistics. I'd like them to have a pretend life; I'd like them to experience magic. Maybe just in a natural world/pagan/hippy mother earth kind of way, instead of a mass marketed kind of way. Secondly, I'm thinking we can't afford kids now, because I can barely afford presents for my mom & sister.
I don't want it to seem like I think I know how to parent or AT ALL are judging other people's decisions. Hell, I went to the high school today to get the registration papers for the exchange students and I actually felt like I might have an anxiety attack, thinking about the responsibility. We're just having fun talking about what we think we would do. It also keeps me positive, when frankly I have some concerns about getting pregnant at all.
We leave this afternoon for San Francisco. I'm really looking forward to it. With the students coming next week I think we'll be very busy for the next month and a half, so it will be really great to have a few days away beforehand. Maybe I'll finally get to relax and read something other than the news, even. I miss books.

